Feedback Circle Reflection Part 1

Reading time: 12-15 minutes

Summary: I invited NVC trainer peers to a feedback circle. I split the 90minute session into two, and asked for the ‘hard stuff’ first. The gifts I got were reflections that included consent, clarity, and .


The invitation I made

I took the transcript of what I said, and edited it. This is more like what I was wanting to say…

I've been thinking a lot about reality recently, about how reality creation is complex, it is both mutually and nonviolently co-created, and dominator claimed. I find that this is especially highlighted through some kinds of feedback that I get. Many people believe that it's okay to offer feedback without consent. I have many examples. As an autistic person, I get told through various feedbacks that I'm not showing up in a way that's welcome. I get pathologised and classified under the mental health categorisation system. As someone that's a trans woman, I get the feedback from men's faces quite often. Such men feel it's okay to tell me that they think I look disgusting. And so I get to learn to engage with that and through choice I get to channel love rather than submit to their judgements.

My archetype, I'm learning to get more confident with, is to channel the archetype of the fool. I see Marshall did that. This morning a facilitator played a clip of Dr Marshall Rosenberg, singing a beautiful song; See Me Beautiful. Part of me senses that he is being really funny, albeit with a very deadpan face. This nurtures me because it lets me know that I'm not alone in my humour style and using humour as part of my educational practise of sharing NVC. Having spoken to those that knew him well about this, they have told me that he used humour in teaching NVC but rarely in private.

I then invited the kind of feedback that I was wanting.

So what I'm going to invite us to do now is let me know, what do I need to know as an NVC candidate? And please don't hold back. Start with the difficult stuff. Start with the really chunky stuff, the stuff that even you might be afraid to say. You sharing your perspective is likely to be a gift, because you can help me be aware of the parts of me that I cannot easily see.

What I was feeling underneath my nerves was tiredness. The weight of accumulated microaggressions that tell me that I don't belong in the world or in some parts of our community of practise, a practise that claims to welcome difference.

In this feedback circle I wanted to get the harsh stuff out the way first for a few reasons. Firstly I know I can hear it, I've built resilience through daily transphobia, daily ableism and a sense that often my playful NVC practise has been ‘policed’ by those who ideate a different idea of how an NVC Trainer might show up. In contrast, it is hard for me to hear celebrations, as they can trigger stories about not being good enough and I become instantly overwhelmed and unable to hear the gifts.

I explained why I was asking, explained my history, explained my strategy, explained my relationship to Marshall Rosenberg, explained my archetype work. However as I made my requests, I didn't notice that I was asking for vulnerability in ways that might be confusing. The full transcript shows my lack of clarity, how I was inviting ‘difficult to hear stuff’ first, which is an unusual request, and asking for difficult to hear stuff, which again might be uncomfortable or difficult request to meet, and furthermore at the same time framing my request within a narrative of bolstering or defence.

M caught this:

I'm a little worried. What I'm hearing is that you've got a plan and a very clear invitation how we can participate, and also a real vulnerable sharing of honesty of how you fielded all of these comments come in at you as though one, they sounds like you didn't get consent to hear them, and two, there's some belief that you're being measured [by self and other..ed] against an ideal and that in and of itself is violent.

She was perceptive and accurate.

I didn't ask if people were resourced to give me difficult feedback. I just asked for it. In NVC we practise seeking consent for receiving, e.g. ‘are you willing to recieve…’. However I can’t recall having witnessed anyone asking consent for soliciting difficult feedback, ‘would you be willing/how would it be to tell me the difficult stuff’. I had not imagined that it might be hard for some people to offer, I had only imagined that people would relish the chance to share how I impact them. In NVC feedback we know that the feedback reflects as much, if not more about the speaker than the receiver. I am amused that this is true in this case as well. What stories we tell ourselves!

What came back

The feedback clustered around a few themes.

Clarity:

K said:

I would like more clarity too about what you're actually inviting. I hear the want for honesty, but I also I want it to be feedback that you can actually receive.

Then Z asked for the invitation in writing, so they could refer back to it. In chat I wrote the following:

I would like to hear any feedback that might be difficult to say or hear first, especially in regards to how I show up. Especially as a participant. Especially as a facilitator. And just reflecting back, that the harshest criticism you get when you walk out the door, so you know that it's coming from people's mouths and it's about them, and then it's harder to really receive information about needs met for people.

Learning: Offer multi sense communication. Prepare words to share.

Consent and Power:

M named it directly. I didn't get consent. I also didn't notice that my self-deprecation might create pressure on participants to manage my emotional state. When I said “I'm not seeing lots of smiles, and that makes me feel really fucking...” I centred myself which is less mutual than I would like. I can see I was asking them to hold me(by smiling – which many did). I had imagined I was demonstrating checking in with what ‘the room’ was doing. I also imagined I was using humour to elicit relief, shared reality and fun.

J said offered:

I put my hand up and took it down a couple of times because it's a reaction to what you're asking rather than actually what you're asking. I haven't been in the same place with you, virtual or otherwise, together. We've had just little bits during virtual retreats where we have been together. So I long for more time with you, in order to have more of experience of each other, so that I would have something to tell you that might be difficult for you to hear.

The more you keep talking about it and welcoming us to a space where we can fart in here and it's okay, where I can trust that other people will hold me and that I can be that relaxed. The more you do that, the more I want to give you the kind of feedback that you find most difficult to hear.

I had imagined that I was giving permission and space to get the difficult stuff said. I had not imagined that I was creating the urge to meet my request. Reflecting on my language, and being more prepared, I can ensure that I frame this more carefully, so as not to conjure difficult stuff if it isn’t there already!

Impact and Rigidity:

A queer, autistic practioner in the group shared:

Because I'm queer and because I'm also autistic, you are a person in the group who I actually understand and like can connect with more than anyone so far. And the thing that that is difficult is that you have articulated a view several times about the mental health field being something that's really difficult for you, and that you really do not appreciate diagnoses, and neither did Marshall.

I felt the same way about the mental health field, but then I became a counselor to try to do it differently, and I work with people like us every day, making our lives wonderful. And so I find myself really wanting to have a connection with you, and also feeling like this is my jackpot, but that you wouldn't like me.

This moment that mattered so much. I've been critical of the mental health system. For me diagnoses have been used to pathologise my autism, my transness, my responses to abuse (depression). It took me decades to find liberation from the system that situates the distress I experienced as being anything other than a limitation in me. For me the liberation came when I understood that my reactions are natural human reactions to systemic or environmental conditions. For my liberation, anger was helpful and a step on my healing journey. I also wanted to share my insight with many others, because I so want less people to have to needlessly suffer as I did. However this person works within that system. My rigidity, passion and lack of complexity contributed to their feeling that they might not get their need for belonging met with me. Holding this stuff with gentleness and care is really hard.

Of course in that moment, I wanted to explain, and talk about intent and my history and the ‘why’. And I have learnt that this will not likely be helpful in that moment, and in that moment, what I need to do is care for impact, to hear the pain and acknowledge and welcome it as the gift that it is.

I reflected back what I heard. Then I said:

I want to explain, if that's okay, a little bit that I, the mental health thing, is a social structure like Google, like other things that I have not been holding with the complexity that supports inclusion and does have caused impact in my strong opinions about stuff in the past. I'm so grateful for you naming that and perhaps giving me a chance to own that. Mental health as a thing does support many, many, many people, and I have yet to find a way to hold it with a gentle criticality that is as supportive as my I might have liked to have done that two years ago.

They said: “I just feel a light expanding in my chest. Feels wonderful.”

I was able to hold my critique of systems and also acknowledge that my rigidity in the past had excluded someone I want connection with. What scares me, is that I see a similar rigidity in others who I can situate as ‘on the other side’, like gender critical ideologues.

So this was *exactly* what I wanted the space to be for. A space for people that I have impacted to be heard. For me to hear them and dance with the impact.

Facilitation style:

Z offered:

I hear you explaining a lot, and sometimes I get lost in a lot of words, and I also might need something visual to kind of remind me what it is you're focusing on. Another piece is that I'll hear you talking about systems, and I hear this tone, and I hear the word “shit” a lot, and I'm like, “Okay, am I comfortable?” And I'm wondering how other people are also comfortable with a lot of cursing in the rooms, you know. And is there some way to ask consent around that?”

Like, I might go to like, oh, is that anger? Is that excitement? I might get confused. Is that anger and judgment, or is that excitement and honesty?

This is useful. The over-explaining, that's a neurodivergent and and a nerves thing. I've been misunderstood so often that I pile on words to ensure I'm understood. And it overwhelms listeners, of course it does. The cursing and intensity is interesting. Is it my ‘natural’ style. A rebellion against the ‘nicey nicey’ of NVC or an ADHD reaction to not being able to sit still enough to be calm in the way that others model NVC.

Learning: Consent for coarse language matters.

Learning: Not everyone reads my excitement and intensity as I might imagine.

Summary

Writing things down matters. It creates multiple ways to access the request/information.

Consent goes both ways. I can't just ask for difficult feedback without checking if people are resourced to give it. Especially when I'm the facilitator. There's power there, even in communities that try to flatten hierarchy.

Over-explaining can be a nervous system response, not generosity. I'm not giving people more clarity, I am overwhelming them. I have self compassion for needing protection (hiding behind words) and shared understanding (too many words).

Self-deprecation creates pressure. When I say “I'm shit at what I do, I fall on my face” I might imagine I'm modelling humility. What participants might hear is “please reassure me” or “don't hurt me, I'm already down”.

Vulnerability without structure becomes performance. I was vulnerable. I named my transness, my autism, my daily reality of harsh feedback. But without clear structure, a container, it risked becoming a wall that made it harder for people to respond. Vulnerability needs container and care, not just exposure. I particularly learnt this in my debrief… K observed that I often name my vulnerablity but not the request/need, I leave it hanging and unfinished. What a gift to learn! I imagined that I was ‘making progress’ by being vulnerable and that alone was a sufficient gift.

How I'm changing my practice

Written invitation, visible throughout. I'll put the request in chat at the start and leave it there. People can refer back. No “what are we doing again?” mid-session.

Consent check built in. Explicit: “please don’t give feedback if you're not resourced or if you haven't had enough time with me. If you need more clarity, let me know.”

Language intensity named upfront. “I want to check how it is for people to hear strong language. There is no demand, choice is important, comfort is important”

Less explanation, more space. I'm practising saying the thing once. Then waiting. The urge to elaborate is my nervous system trying to control how I'm perceived. I can feel that and not act on it.

Self-empathy aloud. When I feel shame or embarrassment in the room, I'm going to name it and give myself empathy. Not “I feel shame and embarrassment for the thing” and then move on. But “I'm feeling shame. I think I might need some understanding. Let me take a breath.” I want to model self-responsibility more and more instead of asking participants to take care of me.

What's still tender

I'm still navigating what it means to pursue NVC trainer certification in a community where DEI and trans lives are contested. Sometimes it seems that people think they're being nonviolent while they feedback that I'm not performing trainer in a way they enjoy.

I'm still learning to hold the fool archetype without making it a shield. Marshall could tell a dead pan joke in service of praxis/education. I'm trying to do something similar. Sometimes it lands. Sometimes it doesn't.

I'm learning what mutuality requires. Not just me going first in vulnerability, even though that really helps, not just me asking for honesty, even though that really helps. I am wanting to create conditions where I can be vulnerable and others can be honest without having a sense of needing to manage me.

Closing

This transcript is part of my certification portfolio. I offer it in vulnerability. I offer it to disrupt with transparency. I offer it as a way to say ‘thank you’ for coming, for your attention, for the gifts of your feedback.

If you're reading this as a trans person, as an autistic person or any marginalised identity. I see you. I'm trying to build rooms where we don't have to leave parts of ourselves at the door, except perhaps that part that is so skilled at performing masking.

you belong. emx


References